Best car insurance: how to compare car insurance rates

Updated 22 November 2026 ยท ClearCost USA ยท 5 min read

The best car insurance is the policy that gives you the cover you need at the lowest total price from a financially sound insurer with good claims service. Nationally, full coverage averaged $187 a month in November 2026 (Insurify), but the same driver can be quoted very different prices by different companies, so comparing at least three quotes is the single best way to get cheap car insurance.
Advertisement

How to compare car insurance quotes like-for-like

  1. Write down your current limits: bodily injury per person/per accident, property damage, uninsured motorist, and your collision and comprehensive deductibles.
  2. Ask every insurer for exactly those limits and deductibles. A cheap quote with state-minimum liability is not comparable to full coverage.
  3. Use the same drivers, cars, garaging ZIP code, annual mileage and violation history on each quote.
  4. Compare the six-month or yearly total including fees, then discounts you qualify for (multi-policy, good student, telematics, paid in full).
  5. Check complaint data on your state insurance department's site and financial strength ratings before you buy.

Free online car insurance quotes are fine for comparison, but confirm the final price after the insurer checks your driving and claims reports.

Cheapest and most expensive states for car insurance

Average full coverage quotes ranged from about $85 a month in New Hampshire to over $300 in Maryland in November 2026. Cheapest: New Hampshire ($85), Wyoming ($94), Alaska ($94), Idaho ($107), Iowa ($111). Most expensive: Maryland ($301), Rhode Island ($295), Delaware ($263), Nevada ($261), Georgia ($259). Large states searched often: California $204, Texas $204, Florida $235, New York $217, Illinois $163 and New Jersey $257 a month for full coverage.

Average car insurance quotes by state, November 2026

StateFull coverage / monthLiability only / monthFull coverage / year
Maryland$301$191$3,612
Rhode Island$295$178$3,540
Delaware$263$167$3,156
Nevada$261$165$3,132
Georgia$259$157$3,108
New Jersey$257$181$3,084
South Carolina$255$159$3,060
Florida$235$143$2,820
Michigan$230$131$2,760
District of Columbia$227$131$2,724
Connecticut$225$161$2,700
Colorado$217$97$2,604
New York$217$145$2,604
Louisiana$208$106$2,496
Virginia$207$118$2,484
California$204$98$2,448
Texas$204$110$2,448
Kentucky$194$121$2,328
Mississippi$186$89$2,232
Washington$184$95$2,208
Minnesota$182$93$2,184
Missouri$180$93$2,160
Oklahoma$169$84$2,028
Arizona$163$91$1,956
Illinois$163$84$1,956
Pennsylvania$161$90$1,932
Kansas$157$79$1,884
Oregon$157$91$1,884
West Virginia$157$83$1,884
South Dakota$152$62$1,824
Arkansas$149$73$1,788
Utah$146$92$1,752
Alabama$142$66$1,704
Montana$141$62$1,692
Maine$139$74$1,668
Vermont$139$58$1,668
Massachusetts$138$102$1,656
Nebraska$135$70$1,620
New Mexico$133$65$1,596
Tennessee$132$60$1,584
Indiana$128$64$1,536
Hawaii$126$62$1,512
Wisconsin$125$57$1,500
Ohio$117$65$1,404
North Dakota$114$66$1,368
North Carolina$113$69$1,356
Iowa$111$56$1,332
Idaho$107$64$1,284
Alaska$94$58$1,128
Wyoming$94$50$1,128
New Hampshire$85$52$1,020

Source: Insurify average quotes, November 2026. Your quote will differ.

Advertisement

What makes car insurance cheaper or more expensive

  • Driving record: one at-fault accident lifts the average annual cost by about 17% and a speeding ticket by about 18% (Experian 2026 averages).
  • Age: drivers under 20 pay roughly 50% more than drivers in their 40s; rates fall through middle age.
  • Where the car is kept: dense cities like NYC cost more than rural ZIP codes because of theft and crash frequency.
  • Car: repair cost, theft rate and safety tech all matter; sports cars and luxury cars cost more.
  • Coverage and deductible: full coverage costs about twice liability only; a $1,000 deductible is cheaper than $500.
  • Credit-based insurance score: used in most states; California, Hawaii, Massachusetts and Michigan restrict it.

How to get cheaper car insurance today

The biggest savings usually come from shopping, not from cutting cover. Ask about bundling with renters or homeowners insurance, a telematics program that tracks safe driving, good-student and defensive driving course discounts, and paying the term in full. "Very cheap car insurance with no deposit" usually means a monthly plan where the first month is the deposit, so the yearly total is what to compare. If you have a loan, keep collision and comprehensive; if the car is worth little, compare dropping them. For teens, adding them to a parent's policy is normally cheaper than a separate policy.

Advertisement

Worked example: same driver, three quotes

A 35-year-old in Texas with one car and a clean record asks three insurers for 100/300/100 liability, $1,000 deductibles and uninsured motorist cover. Quotes come back at $1,920, $2,450 and $2,880 a year. Picking the lowest saves $960 a year against the highest, more than most single discounts. The Texas average for full coverage was about $2,448 a year, so the lowest quote is below average and the highest above it.

How we got these numbers

State averages are Insurify's average quotes for November 2026 (full coverage and liability only). Accident and ticket effects are ratios from Experian's 2026 average cost by driving record. The estimator multiplies the state average by these ratios.

Figures were checked on 22 November 2026. Averages are estimates, not quotes or advice; rules and prices change, so confirm with the official source or a licensed professional before you act.

Sources and further reading

Questions people ask

Which company has the best car insurance?
No single company is best for everyone. The cheapest insurer differs by state, age and record. Compare prices from at least three insurers, then check complaint ratios on your state insurance department site and financial strength ratings.
How do I compare car insurance rates fairly?
Ask each insurer for the same liability limits, deductibles, drivers, cars and mileage. Compare the six-month or yearly total including fees and the discounts you actually qualify for.
What is the cheapest car insurance in California?
In November 2026 California averaged about $204 a month for full coverage and $98 for liability only. California does not allow credit scores in pricing, so driving record, mileage and experience matter more.
How much is cheap car insurance in Texas?
The Texas average was about $110 a month for liability only and $204 for full coverage in November 2026. Drivers with clean records who shop around often find quotes below these averages.
Is car insurance expensive in Florida and New York?
Yes. Florida averaged about $235 and New York $217 a month for full coverage, above the $187 national average. NYC ZIP codes are usually higher than upstate New York.
Can I get car insurance with no deposit?
Many insurers let you start a monthly policy where the first payment is due at purchase. That first payment is effectively the deposit. Compare the full term cost, because monthly plans can carry fees.
Do online car insurance quotes change after I buy?
They can. Insurers verify your motor vehicle report, claims history and, in most states, credit-based insurance score before finalizing. Answer questions accurately to avoid a price change or a cancelled policy.
How often should I compare car insurance rates?
At every renewal, and after any big change: moving, buying a car, adding a teen driver, getting married or after a ticket drops off your record (often after three to five years).
What is the best car insurance for teens?
The best value is usually adding the teen to a parent's policy with a good-student discount and a safe, modest car. Separate teen policies cost much more because drivers under 20 have the highest rates.
Does comparing car insurance quotes hurt my credit?
No. Insurance quotes use a soft inquiry that does not affect your credit score.

Results are estimates for information only, not financial advice. Read the full disclaimer.

More free calculators

Advertisement